
My favorite pattern sold nothing for seven months. Then I made one TikTok.
If a pattern you’re proud of isn’t selling, it might not be the pattern. Rusty the Wood Owl, the design I’m most proud of, went up on Etsy at the end of February and sold nothing for seven months. Then I posted one TikTok about how confused I was that he wasn’t selling. That one post got his first sale, and two more people bought him a few days later. Nobody could buy what nobody saw.
Rusty
Rusty is a wood owl, about six inches tall, in copper, taupe and linen cotton. He has big ringed eyes, little copper feet, and colorful wings that sit on his sides.
He took about a month from starting the design to finishing him, getting him tested and putting him out. I was really, really proud of him. I thought he was a creative design for an owl, and I didn’t see anything like him on Etsy.
So I listed him and waited.
Seven months of nothing
And nothing happened. Not one sale. Weeks went by, then months.
I was really surprised by that. And honestly, I was disappointed that people didn’t love him, or even like him, as much as I did.
That’s the vulnerable part of putting a pattern out there that I don’t think gets talked about enough. Writing a pattern is a lot of work, and testing it is a lot of work. Then you publish it, and nothing.
The TikTok
About two weeks ago I made a TikTok about exactly this. Rusty, and my confusion as a pattern designer about why he wasn’t selling.
That TikTok was the first time ever that I posted something where I was basically talking to my phone. Or really, to some future, unknown audience.
That post alone got him his first sale. Then a couple of days later, two more people bought him.
Three sales after seven months of zero, and none of it was because the pattern changed. The pattern was the same pattern. The only thing that changed was that people saw him.
That was enlightening for me. I wasn’t putting myself out there. I wasn’t marketing. I expected to post it and see what happens, and what happens is nothing.
What I got wrong
Looking back, this is what I’d do differently:
- I let my Instagram die. I had an account, @amanitacrochetshop, and I just stopped posting. On Etsy you’re competing with so many patterns that you can’t count on people stumbling across yours.
- I treated publishing as the finish line. A month of design and testing, and then I listed him and walked away. The listing was the start of the work, not the end of it.
- I didn’t have my own website until just recently. I only built amanitacrochet.shop in September. I should have had ownership of my patterns and my designs from day one, instead of everything living on somebody else’s platform.
- I never decided what this was. Is this a business? Is it a hobby? I didn’t know, so I didn’t treat it like either. The truth is I still kind of struggle with that.
| What I did with Rusty | What I’m doing now |
|---|---|
| Listed him on Etsy and waited | Talking about my patterns where people actually are |
| Let Instagram go quiet | Trying to post, even when it doesn’t come naturally |
| Only had an Etsy shop | Have my own site for my patterns |
| Kept my accounts private | Putting myself out there, slowly |
That last row is the hard one for me. I’ve always been a very private person. My social media accounts were always private. Putting myself and my work out there doesn’t come naturally, and I’m still getting comfortable with it.
I’m not really there yet. Making a video still feels like talking to my phone while I’m alone in my office. I’m still learning, and I’m still growing.
Why I keep designing anyway
Even though it’s fair to say I haven’t had much success yet, the pull to design patterns is still there.
I’m not someone who can draw. I never thought of myself as artistic. So being able to crochet something and then write my own pattern for it is fulfilling in a way I didn’t expect. It feels like something hard that I did.
And I still find joy in people creating the art that I’ve created.
I also grew as a crocheter. You really learn a lot building your own pattern. You grow as an artist in fiber arts.
But it teaches you other things too, and not all of them are fun:
- Humility. The design you love most might not be the one people buy.
- Patience. Seven months is a long time to wait for a first sale.
- Dealing with disappointment. And deciding to keep going anyway.
- Marketing. Learning what you can actually control to get more people to see your work.
If your pattern isn’t selling either
I’m not going to pretend I have this figured out. But if you’re where I was, staring at a listing you’re proud of and wondering why nobody wants it, this is what I’d ask myself first.
Has anyone actually seen it? Not the listing sitting in a sea of other listings. Has anyone seen you talk about it, why you made it, what you love about it?
For Rusty, the answer was no. One honest post fixed that more than seven months of waiting did.
If this feels scary, I get it
If you’re feeling alone in this, you’re not. If posting feels scary or mortifying, I get it.
My following is still small. I’m not what anyone would consider a successful pattern designer, and that’s okay. I’m okay with just going through the process. It’s helping me grow, and it’s helping me learn.
And the people who have connected with me and commented have been so positive. Honestly, it’s been inspiring. It’s made me want to connect with more people in this community. Putting yourself out there can bring that sense of community too.
I grew. I’m learning. And I think I’m getting better. But I’m still in that vulnerable place. If you are too, I get it. But I think it’s still worth pushing through. Keep trying. As long as the desire and the passion for designing, crocheting or knitting is still there, it’s a worthy pursuit.
That’s what I’m doing.
If you design on the couch the way I do, the NodeStitch iPhone app is where my next pattern usually starts: a photo of the notebook page, or rows dictated as I go.